is luggage roof bag on 2008 acura mdx rack a good idea

[thepites]

I have a 2008 Acura MDX with the factory rack on it. I'm not really interested in outdoor euipment carriers...basically to get kids back and forth to college and the cartop cargo bags look like a good solution. Wondering what others think about these roof bags.

[tuff_girl]

I personally wouldn't go for anything other than the Thule 867 Tahoe roof bag. This is the best luggage roof bag available for good reason. It is pretty much the only waterproof roof bag available and it also holds a lot of stuff without looking bulky. It'll hold just about as much stuff as any plastic hard shell roof box and is much more convenient. It attaches right to your 2008 Acura MDX factory rack.